Academic agencies also need to be kept in check, professor argues ,
In recent months, many major universities have pledged to preserve an administrative neutrality policy, meaning that their leaders wo n’t send memos to their respective campus communities about pressing social and political issues.
Departmental statements purporting to represent one singular view of all faculty remain a significant and ongoing issue, according to one professor, who claims the trend is good but does n’t go far enough.
In a recent op-ed for Inside Higher Ed, San Diego State University English Professor Peter C. Herman wrote,” It does n’t matter if the president is neutral if academic departments advertise their political leanings, as many do.”
Individual professors will bring into the classroom intolerance when a department claims to hold a particular social position but does not tolerate opposition.
Herman wrote:
For instance, the seats of San Francisco State University’s College of Ethnic Studies wrote,” We strongly condemn the Israeli murder and movement of Palestinians in Gaza,” in a statement released today. We demand a full stop to the genocide, the distribution of humanitarian assistance, and a peace immediately.
Also, a collective of more than 100 sex research agencies and courses across the U. S. and Canada issued a statement in 2021 declaring,” We stand in cooperation with the people of Palestine”. The statement is completely obvious that there is no argument here:” We do not adhere to a’ both sides ‘ speech that negates the military, economic, internet and global energy that Israel has over Palestine”.
Herman argued that individuals are unapologetically leading the way, and this is unfortunate to be the case.
” Unsurprisingly, kids are following their academics in disallowing contradictory opinions. According to a recent study conducted by the Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression on free speech, censorship and self-censorship are prevalent on college campuses, and frequently enough, it is not the professors who are policing talk, he wrote.
Herman pointed to a recent University of California system legislation that forbids “political statements on college webpages.” Solutions are in the future, Herman said. He also flagged Harvard’s independence plan, which” now covers all executives, supervisors, office chair and university councils”.
But, “both steps have been met with stiff opposition by instructors, and various universities have never followed their case”.
” Until supervisors, office eyes, faculty and students embrace intellectual and political diversity, administrative independence is no different than virtue-signaling, i. e., a dull movement that does nothing to address the true problem”, Herman wrote.
Less: Administrative neutrality approved at many main campuses nationwide ,
Photo: Jay Yuan / Shutterstock
Follow The College Fix on Twitter and Like us on Twitter.