Scholars accuse the move of being an “intentional attempt to judge Christian beliefs” and an “ignorance of Western intellectual tradition.”
For its “expressions of Christian faith,” Geoffrey Chaucer’s” The Canterbury Tales” received a content notice from Nottingham University.
Critics claim that Christian styles are inherent in mediaeval writing and that students studying texts from this time period may expect these themes.
Chaucer’s job, published in the 1400s, is “one of the most famous works of mediaeval books” and social comedy, according to The Becket Story, a University of York source on mediaeval authors. Chaucer’s story tells of a spiritual trip to visit the shrine of Saint Thomas Becket, the slain Archbishop of Canterbury.
A UoN spokesperson, Emma Thorne, informed The College Fix via email that the school did n’t issue trigger warnings but rather” content notices” about the subjects” they will be studying so they know what themes are covered and can speak to their tutors about any questions or issues before” ( instead ).
The UK’s Newcastle University notes that the name” content warning” is used instead because it is” a gentle indication of when content is of a sympathetic nature and may cause distress,” rather than Thorne’s explanation of the distinction between trigger instructions and information finds.
A set caution has a more disturbing tone than a typical action or reaction, according to the university.
According to Thorne, Thorne told The Fix,” Yet those students who are practicing Christians did discover aspects of the late-medieval view they may encounter in Chaucer and others alienating and strange,” citing Nottingham University’s declaration on the new warnings.
” All students properly value knowing in advance about some ideas that will be covered, for example, the anti-Islamic views of some feudal artists”, she stated.
This material see encourages issues to be raised in order to place the fabric in a properly important framework, Thorne said. It does not deter students from encountering any of this substance.
A module on Chaucer and other writers from medieval times was included in the school’s notices. The warnings do n’t address the themes of antisemitism or sexually explicit language that are present in the story, even though they warn students about violence, mental illness, and expressions of Christian faith.
MORE: Princeton library adds trigger warnings to ‘ offensive’ archive materials
Thorne told The Fix that while Chaucer’s Canterbury Tales do indeed contain both sexual frankness and anti-Semitism, the content notice only applies to the specific texts studied on the module, not Chaucer’s works in their entire entirety. Thorne then asked why there was no content warning about the sexual and antisemitic themes in some of Chaucer’s works.
By warning students about Chaucer’s story’s religious themes, professors and historians have criticized the university for “demeaning education.” Such themes, they suggest, should be obvious to anyone studying medieval English literature, according to the Daily Mail.
According to Owen Anderson, a professor of philosophy at Arizona State University, “warnings about Christianity are attempts to censor Christian beliefs,” Anderson wrote in an email to The College Fix.
” It is silly and shows the feeble mindedness of the secular academy”, he stated.
” ]I ] n a different way, Christianity is troubling”, Anderson stated. It demonstrates that we have sinned against God and that there are unjust consequences to this sin. However, it is the only source of hope from this truth”.
He added that” to intentionally disregard that Christianity is the only source of true hope,” is what he meant.
Similarly, Jeremy Black, a British historian and former professor of history, criticized the move in an email to The Fix. He thinks the university’s decision is” a failure to comprehend the Christian foundation of a large portion of the Western literary tradition.”
This is” a major defect that compromises intellectual integrity”, Black stated.
The debate over Chaucer’s work began to intensify in 2021. Academics in America and the United Kingdom took actions to prevent the “father of English literature” from being labeled a rapist, racist, and anti-Semite, The College Fix previously reported.  ,
Cambridge University English Professor Jill Mann, for example, resigned from her role on the board of the Chaucer Review, an academic journal, following the publication of an essay titled” New Feminist Approaches to Chaucer” . ,
In the essay, authors Samantha Katz Seal and Nicole Sidhu called for feminists to “move past Chaucer”, labeling him” a rapist, a racist, an anti-Semite”, and criticizing his portrayal of a world dominated by males, Christians, the wealthy, and whites.
MORE: University puts trigger warning on Hemingway’s ‘ Old Man and the Sea’:
IMAGE: Great Books on Tape/Youtube
Follow The College Fix on Twitter and Like us on Facebook.
