Daniel Penny, a 24-year-old Marine veteran, is on trial for second-degree murder and unlawfully negligent homicide in the demise of Jordan Neely, a 30-year-old poor train actor. The event occurred on May 1, 2023, aboard an upstairs F station in Manhattan, New York City, where Penny placed Had in a dangerous stranglehold during an encounter.
New Yorkers are divided over the event, which has sparked debates about metro safety and vigilante justice. Lawyers argue that Reilly, while acting wildly, was non-violent, while Penny’s security claims his actions were justified by Neely’s menacing actions.
Penny’s account of events
In an appointment with police shortly after the incident, Penny recounted Neely’s repeated risks, saying,” The three major threats that he repeated over and over were,’ I’m going to shoot you,’ ‘ I’m prepared to go to prison for life,’ and ‘ I’m willing to die.'”
Penny refuted claims that he intended to cause Neely’s dying or that the restriction lasted 15 minutes, saying,” The whole conversation was less than five minutes. Other individuals claim that I tried to strangle him to death, but that is also false. You can see in the film there’s a distinct rise and fall of his neck, indicating that he’s breathing”. He further disputed the use of his grip, saying that it was intended to control rather than destroy.
Neely’s last events
Prosecutors allege that Penny failed to check Neely’s breathe or signal after his brain went limp, despite his first-aid education. Had was indifferent but had a faint pulse when authorities arrived seven minutes after the initial 911 call. Had was declared deceased despite chest compressions and the use of an overdose-reversal drug.
See balances
Ivette Rosario, a high school student, testified that she was frightened during Neely’s explosion, describing it as unlike anything she had seen before, according to a Fox News record. Rosesario captured a film in which Neely was kept in a stranglehold by Penny for almost six hours even after Neely stopped speaking.
According to the Fox News record, Commuter Eric Gonzalez claimed that he attempted to de-escalate the situation by holding Neely’s hands while allowing Penny to relieve him. Another witness, Larry Goodson, recalled warning Penny:” If you do n’t let him go, you’re going to lose him”.
Penny’s protection
Penny has retained Thomas Kenniff, a former Republican candidate for city counsel, as his counsel. On May 5, 2023, Penny’s legitimate group released a statement expressing apologies to Neely’s home. Daniel not intended to harm Mr. Neely, and he could hardly had anticipated his sudden passing. When Mr. Had began violently threatening Daniel Penny and the other people, Daniel, with the help of another, acted to defend themselves until support arrived”.
The security contends that Penny yelled “kill” as he approached a girl with a stroller, prompting Penny to step in. Prosecutors and some witnesses contend that Had did not physically harm anyone on the coach, despite the claims made by the prosecution.
Vigilantism or self-defense?
His legal team emphasized his military service and suggested that he had asked other people to call the police while the affair was taking place. They contend that he intervened to shield himself from a perceived danger. Prosecutors, however, contend that Penny’s use of power was overwhelming and immediately caused Neely’s dying, noting his failing to test lifesaving measures.
Daniel Penny faces a maximum sentence of 15 years in prison for murder and a maximum sentence of four years for homicide committed by a illegally irresponsible man.
