Joy Reid, a previous MSNBC host, alleged that the Roman Empire collapsed as a result of a lack of diversity and warned that the United States might experience the same fate if it doesn’t fully accept efforts to promote diversity, equity, and addition. She sparked controversy.
Reid criticized main U.S. companies for reversing DEI initiatives during a life Substack podcast interview with Wajahat Ali, tying the situation to wider social and political shifts under the Trump administration.
Joy Reid claims that if variety isn’t promoted, the US will” carefully end and aging” like the” Roman Empire.”
READ THIS PICTURE: https ://t.co/KyPbDibYpM photograph. https ://twitter.com/fY4QelwK6R
— Washington Examiner ( @dcexaminer ) April 28, 2025
She also cited statistical trends, noting that Generation Alpha, those born after 2010, are now overwhelmingly nonwhite, and that the United States will no longer have a light bulk by 2045.
We are basically a Latin American nation, and our appearance will be more similar. The majority of people will not be white, but the majority will be colored, she continued.
Reid’s remarks immediately received criticism, particularly from liberals and historians.
In a bit titled” No, Joy Reid: Rome didn’t drop due to a lack of “diversity,” David Sypher Jr., a writer for the Spectator, refuted her historic says.
According to Sypher, the Roman Empire was one of the most various societies in history, far from being uniform.
Rome’s troops were compelled to march across the Germanic boundaries, cross the Atlantic, and into the middle east. Septimius Severus, an émigré, was born in modern-day Libya, he wrote.
He attributed the emperor’s decline to deep-seated issues like political corruption, untenable taxes, falling political standards, low birthrates, and relying on slave labour.
No diversity authority could have ended a historical decay that had affected Roman society’s quite core, according to Sypher.
He added that demographic decline and a decline in postcolonial confidence are the root causes of Europe’s contemporary crisis, as well as cultural composition and demographic decline. Concerns about the future economic and cultural conservation are raised by the fact that Europe’s fertility prices have fallen far below replacement levels.
Other people on the internet quickly criticized Reid’s historic research, calling it both false and false.
TRUMP’s 100 DAYS: HOW TO MEASURE?
Because the kingdom was multi-ethnic, including North Africans, Middle Easterners, and Europeans, one person wrote on X,” This state is entertaining, but it also is fully generally false.” No racial composition caused its decline, according to the statement “economic instability, defense overextension, and invasions.”
Another stated that the fall of the Roman Empire was not due to racism; rather, it was the result of military overreach, economic decline, corruption, and invasions by various groups ( like the Huns, Vandals, and Visigoths ), none of which can be attributed to a single “racial” cause.
