Nothing can be moved in gang-controlled areas of Haiti without causing them to lose: not food, not energy, not yet humanitarian assistance.
According to Alfred Metellus, the country’s finance minister, gangs that charge$ 2, 000 to allow for a shipping container’s passage are extorting up to$ 75 million annually from the ransoms they demand to allow goods to pass through the Dominican Republic. This year, Metellus made the comments in an interview with Haiti’s Le Nouvelliste paper.
Concerns are raised that a program by the U.S. State Department to classify the nation’s gangs as international terrorist organizations could worsen suffering at a time when almost 250, 000 of the country’s one million internally displaced live in makeshift camps, some with no latrines and dirt floors.
” Practically, virtually no industrial or humanitarian activity occurs in or near Port-au-Prince without some kind of negotiation or settlement to groups,” the truth is. According to Jake Johnston, an expert on Haiti with the Center for Economic and Policy Research and writer of” Aid State: Elite Panic, Disaster Capitalism, and the Battle to Control Haiti,” even the U.S. adviser acknowledged speaking with criminals.
” This coverage is likely to lead to more loneliness of Haiti, a de facto embargo that affects the most underprivileged and doesn’t significantly affect the gangs ‘ power,” he continued.
Following a presentation by the State Department to members of Congress about the planned title, which was first reported by the Miami Herald earlier this month, two Democratic lawmakers on Wednesday echoed Johnston’s problems. The Trump presidency has previously imposed on a number of Latin American criminal organizations the use of the ancestor-old Alien Enemies Act. The Viv Ansanm group coalition in Haiti, which is currently in charge of up to 90 % of the city of Port-au-Prince, and the Gran Grif gang that is active in some of the rural Artibonite region, could use the title to attack the United States government.
A senior administration official told the Herald at the time that the program would place crew people and their supporters at risk of receiving legal punishment, including possible confinement in El Salvador’s maximum-security prison.
Although the program has the support of some Haitian organizations, it raises the possibility that aid organizations and other organizations will have to make the difficult decision between attempting to assist at the risk of being labeled terrorists or allowing the population to continue to suffer.
Rep. Gregory Meeks of New York, a top member of the House Foreign Affairs Committee, and Rep. Sheila Cherfilus-McCormick of Florida, the single Haitian-American part in the country and present co-chair of the House Haiti conference, both sent a letter to Secretary of State Marco Rubio on Wednesday, saying they were “grave concerns” about the title.
The lawmakers are concerned that it will unknowingly worsen Haitians ‘ suffering and aid groups in gaining control. They want solutions from Rubio regarding the justification for the title.
We are concerned that an FTO title, absent a clear, complete U.S. approach to beat the criminals and their supporters, is counterproductive and will only intensify Haitians ‘ suffering, the politicians said.
Meeks and Cherfilus-McCormic noted that while dysentery and lice are becoming more prevalent in Haiti, the State Department has previously cut funding for humanitarian projects and health solutions. Haitians will get punished even more if support is delivered across Port-au-Prince and the Artibonite region, they claimed.
A foreign-terrorist organization’s designation “imposes extensive legal and financial sanctions that deter non-governmental agencies and international companies from operating because they are afraid of facing legal consequences,” the legislators wrote.
The representatives are not the only ones who are concerned about the potential chilling influence that the title might have on the delivery of aid to Haiti, where non-governmental organizations, community groups, and others use different methods, including making donations to gangs, to obtain humanitarian assistance for those who reside under the handle of the armed groups.
Some do so through “foundations” that various groups have established as sides for the delivery of aid. Support organizations, however, are so reluctant to discuss the situation informally, even in private. They note they are concerned about the growing humanitarian crisis and are reluctant to discuss the organized title.
We do not express our opinions on any State’s use of such names and we do not speak out in public about them, according to a spokesman for the International Committee of the Red Cross, which is based in Haiti. ” Nevertheless, the ICRC will generally appeal to all parties involved to make all necessary efforts to avoid further humanitarian effects on the ground, to facilitate philanthropic action, and to preserve the needed humanitarian space. Mainly, we urge all parties concerned to protect the population and stop a philanthropic collapse in the nation.”
The United Nations noted in a new report released on Wednesday that the human rights situation in the first third of this year was marked by numerous large attacks, including deaths, robberies, and physical violence.
Between January and March, the report stated that at least 1, 617 people died and 580 were injured in crime involving members of the population, including members of military groups, self-defense organizations, and people of color. 161 payment kidnappings for ransom were also reported at the same time, 63 % of them occurring in the Artibonite place, where two Kenyan police officers were also killed this time.
The violence has increased, and there has also changed, allowing military organizations to no longer depend on kidnappings as much as they do on their blackmail plots. The Global Initiative Against Transnational Organized Crime, a Swiss-based organization, said in its most recent statement that examines the recent push by Haiti’s groups to develop their regional control, adding that this has allowed them to “more place themselves within local markets and making it more difficult to destroy them. According to the report, the gangs levy taxes on all activities, including those that occur within the territories they control, as well as those that occur along the country’s main roads, as well as those that occur close to port or border infrastructure.
The future of the Kenya-led Multinational Security Support mission is uncertain, and even the U.S. Drug Enforcement Administration office isn’t active, which has raised questions about how the U.S. intends to arrest gang leaders when there are no troops in the country.
” Some U.S. officials view the FTO designation as a means of escalating tension and putting gang supporters at risk. According to Diego Da Rien, a Haiti specialist with the International Crisis Group, which closely monitors the security crisis, “it could also make it easier to go after individuals or networks involved in arms trafficking.” However,” an FTO designation’s negative aspects frequently outweigh its positive aspects.”
Da Rien argued that the designation “is a heavily politicized tool that’s rarely reversible and has limited coercive effect on actors already outside the law.” The FTO label makes that much more difficult if the goal is ever to put gangs in a legal framework.
He said that Haiti’s gang problem, which includes the recruitment of children, is unlikely to be solved by force alone, and that it will eventually necessitate” a demobilization process, including exit ramps for minors, something an FTO designation would make difficult.
“FTO designations would also interfere with local efforts to reduce violence, humanitarian aid, and even trade, especially since the majority of access and commerce involve negotiation,” added Da Rien.
Due to the severe civil and criminal penalties imposed on FTOs, he said,” Businesses and aid groups in these kinds of situations frequently overcomply, cutting off operations completely even if enforcement is limited.”
President Donald Trump has cited the Alien Enemies Act in his administration to pursue noncitizens, and he has designated six criminal organizations from Latin America as foreign terrorist organizations. However, both his broad use of executive power and his designation have come under fire because Venezuelan nationals who are suspected of being Tren de Aragua gang members do not have any criminal records.
Da Rien and Johnston are concerned about how the designation might be used to justify deportations or denials of visas for Haitians.
According to Johnston,” This seems more about domestic politics and providing the administration with a justification for deporting upwards of hundreds of thousands of Haitians” than about improving the security situation there.
___
© 2025 Miami Herald.
Tribune Content Agency, LLC distributed.
