What are the chances?
That thing that “never happens” happened yet again last week: A biological male competing against females won first place in two track events.
It happened in (surprise!) Maine, which so far has held firm against President Trump’s executive order banning biological men from competing against women in interscholastic athletics.
In what appears to have been a tri-meet, North Yarmouth Academy junior Soren Stark-Chessa won the girls 800 meter and 1600 meter (mile) runs, the latter by almost 20 seconds.
As noted by Outkick, the 800 event was a closer race with Yarmouth High’s Lilah Connor finishing second by one-and-a-half seconds. In a video (below) you can see Connor shaking her head in dismay after crossing the finish line.
The hilarious thing about Stark-Chessa’s victories is that his winning times suck. He won his events with a 2:43.31 and a 5:57.27 respectively.
Given that the meet appeared to have been a local one between three schools, I had a sneaky suspicion he did “just enough” to win … without making it look too lopsided.
Lo and behold it appears I was right: Last year as a sophomore, Stark-Chessa won the state “Class C” girls 800 championship with a time of 2:19.72 (ten seconds ahead of the second place girl, which is rather substantial for that distance), and finished 3rd in the 1600 with a 5:10.08, both substantially faster.
🚨🚨🚨Insanity. Yesterday a trans-identified boy, Soren Stark-Chessa, racing for North Yarmouth Academy/Maine Coast Waldorf High School, won 1st place in the girls’ 800 meter and the girls’ 1600 meter run.
Watch the expression on the face of the 1st place girl, Lilah Conner,… pic.twitter.com/hvXLHqbkde
— Beth Bourne (@bourne_beth2345) May 3, 2025
But even those (girls’) championship times are at best mediocre for high school boys. Had he run in those boys’ championship competitions, Stark-Chessa would have finished 19th in the 800 meters and 22nd in the 1600.
(Disclosure: Yours truly was a track guy who ran the 400 and 800 meters in high school — best times 49.8 and 2:03.00 respectively — but I ran a 5:03.5 mile in 8th grade. My younger sister would go on to heights of much greater magnitude.)
MORE: Transgender athletes trounce the female competition
Stark-Chessa (pictured) apparently began identifying as female sometime between his freshman and sophomore year as he competed on the boys’ track team in 9th grade, according to Outkick.
Stark-Chessa also has been an all-state “girls” cross country runner and an all-conference “girls” Nordic skier. In the fall of 2023, a parent of two girls who raced against Stark-Chessa in cross country said her kids were in a “lose-lose situation.”
“They don’t want to pretend Stark-Chessa is a girl and congratulate him on beating females,” the parent said according to The Lion. “But they fear they will be seen as ‘hateful’ or bad sports otherwise.”
Oddly enough Stark-Chessa’s parents are both college professors. Soren’s dad, Frank Chessa, is a professor of medicine and associate course director of ethics and professionalism at Tufts University School of Medicine.
He also serves as director of clinical ethics at Maine Medical Center the Gender Care Clinic of which provides “treatment to patients of all ages with both pediatric and adult services.”
The Lion reported the Gender Care Clinic offered “surgical consultations to both children and adults”; however, the clinic’s website currently states such is offered only to those over age 18 (and with a “mental health letter of referral”).
Soren’s mom, Susan Stark (pictured), teaches philosophy at Bates College where she’s at work on a pair of projects, according to her faculty page.
The first is “a defense of the moral and social imperative of making reparations, not only for institutionalized slavery, colonialism, and genocide, but also for ongoing racist policies and white supremacy.”
In a 2022 paper, Stark notes one reparative approach is returning “stolen” land to descendants of original indigenous inhabitants (“historical injustices must be acknowledged, addressed, and repaired—that their significance overrides any harm caused by returning the stolen land”).
The second project deals with “reproductive ethics” for which Stark argues that “reproductive justice […] requires that midwifery and obstetric care address structural racisms and other forms of oppression in their practices and in the education of their practitioners.”
MORE: Parents of transgender female track athlete: ‘cruel’ to make him run against boys
IMAGE CAPTION & CREDIT: A mom holds a sign protesting boys competing against girls; Crazy Vibes/X. INTERIOR IMAGES: Jennifer Sey/X; Bates College
Like The College Fix on Facebook / Follow us on Twitter
