ANALYSIS:’ Nuanced ‘ hate offense allegation at Gettysburg College stalled as sufferer goes calm, rumors swirl
Despite initial studies, it now appears that a student had the n-word engraved in his neck by a stare, which may not have actually been a love crime.
The alleged victim’s family has remained silent, and several observers have posted on social media saying they do n’t believe the original story is accurate.
The insult was etched into a teammate’s figure by a sophomore sprinter at Gettysburg College, which was identified and confirmed by The College Fix as Aidan Ochoa. As rumors that the person’s chest had been” carved” into the n-word were widely reported, the incident in September caused disagreement and worry.
The family’s statement to the scholar paper,” Our brother became the victim of a love crime,” was likewise decried.
He was the only person of color present at this meeting, so it is important to keep that in mind. The disgusting act was committed by a colleague student-athlete, one he considered his friend, one whom he trusted. The N-word was etched across this student’s stomach using a package cutter.
That Ochoa had the word written into his chest is n’t in question. The subject of investigation is the motivation and circumstances, with some claiming that it was probably never some terrible hate crime.
The think left the team after Ochoa and the alleged culprit both left. Some people have questioned how victimized Ochoa was in this case, despite the fact that he was also fired from the group.
A picture on TikTok, along with other opinions online, allege Ochoa consented to the attack, perhaps under the influence of alcohol.
Despite the tips of the Pennsylvania school, Ochoa and his family have chosen to not report the incident to local law enforcement. According to Fox 29, the affair was only discovered after the internet began to cover it. According to ABC 27, Adams County District Attorney Brian Sinnett was first not aware of the allegations.
Also, the home has not responded to the Harrisburg unit of the NAACP, despite especially asking it for help in investigating what happened, according to preliminary reports.
A regional , NAACP representative told The Fix via mobile on Tuesday the team has reached out to the community about moving forward, but to no cost.  , The state NAACP declined to comment when asked about the inspection position, cooperation with law enforcement, and complaints of eating.
” However, we are unable to respond to the questions listed in your email at this time”, President Stacey Taylor told The Fix via internet Nov. 15.
The child’s mother declined to comment when reached via internet by The Fix, and rather deferred to the mom’s attorney, Bobby DiCello.
In the last two days, DiCello has not responded to two letters. Caitlin Whitehurst, his communications director, told The Fix on Tuesday night that she would try to get a post by the day’s finish. The lawyer has not yet made a remark.
The Fix asked for comment on what instrument was used ( there was first says it was a “box cutting” but college authorities said it was “plastic or ceramic” equipment ). Additionally, The Fix requested to solve the stories that beer was a source of drinking.
Gettysburg College declined to comment, citing privacy rules. The Pennsylvania Human Relations Commission and the NAACP have not yet spoken to the university, according to the school’s statement to The Fix.
Director of Communications Jamie Yates told The Fix on October 31 that the learner responsible for the scratching is no longer a student at the College and that they are working together to move things forward.
She claimed that the NAACP and Human Relations Commission have not reached out to the investigators because the matter is” closed.”
Alleged target flaunted insult, at first
A Texas Christian University athlete named Brianna Brand, who frequently makes videos commenting on cultural issues and various news stories, first made a comment about the story by expressing her serious concern and shock.
In a subsequent video posted on TikTok, Brand claimed that a Gettysburg College student contacted her and inquired as to what reportedly really happened. She claimed that” two individuals were drinking in a college dorm house room” was the beginning of the incident.
This student at Gettysburg College told Brand that the sufferer is 25 % dark, and that she wanted people to know that he is a “person of shade.” The student’s communication was shared by Brand with The Fix, who could not be reached for further discussion.
But according to the source, Ochoa” consensually … asked Student B to create the n-word into his chest”, and that” no one was held down, and no one was forced to perform anything”.
That is in line with another critic who claims to be the parent of a Gettysburg College pupil and who wrote in the comments section of a pupil magazine article on October 13:” My child is a pupil on campus, has a course with him, and knows the truth that he was responsible in said incident.”
At least some of the claims were made informally, such as that one man allegedly allegedly allegedly allegedly allegedly allegedly allegedly allegedly allegedly allegedly allegedly allegedly allegedly allegedly allegedly allegedly allegedly carved into another man with one hand while holding the victim down on the ground with one finger.
The Gettysburg College cause alleged Ochoa was really “flaunting” the n-word to friends, but then changed his story after upperclassmen reported the incident, for dread he would get in trouble.
Brand points out that it is unclear whether the claim is entirely accurate, but she said she frequently believed the claim that it “makes sense” because she “was wondering how one person may carve this word into a person’s skin without getting help.”
The Fix contacted the school about the TikTok video’s claims that Ochoa had drank and consented. Nobody was given.
‘ Bizarre story ‘: Law professor says something is amiss about situation
Another man who questioned the tale is a former federal prosecutor, Army captain, and recent teacher at Widener University. When the announcement first appeared in late September, Professor F. Lee Francis had raised objections to the theory.
In a phone interview on November 7 Francis made fresh remarks to The College Fix regarding the investigation and the fresh ideas being made about TikTok.
When asked about the Human Relations Commission’s investigation into the situation, Francis responded,” I really looked at the legislation that addresses the payment, and they basically have authority to investigate.”
The home asked the commission to investigate, although in a public speech, the committee said it could no.
On November 11, representative Amanda Brothman told The Fix,” The PHRC is unable to post on any admitted issue that may or may not have been filed with our agency.”
” I just wonder if they are hesitant to get involved because of the gimmicks, or maybe there is n’t enough evidence,” Professor Francis said.
Francis and The Fix asked for his comments on the TikTok video, as well as what the home and the school should do about the disagreement. He claimed that if there was any “animus” or “bias,” a hate murder charge may be brought against the perpetrator. A prosecutor would take into account” consent”, the legal scholar said.
The prosecutor wo n’t have much of a case if this turns out to be some sort of party trick and people are changing their stories, he said.
In response to the film, Francis said,” People are starting to understand or at least recognize that things are not adding up, and I believe that’s the problem.”
” No one else is involved, no one holds anyone down, something just does n’t seem right”, Francis said, adding the college needs to be open about the results of the investigation.
Gettysburg had “remedy any notion of wrongdoing or of prejudice that’s involved”, he said.
” I think the school should …at least provide the public with some sort of peace of mind that, one, the matter has been addressed” and” some kind of training on this that these things do n’t happen in the future”.
He said the “main objective” should be ensuring students understand it is “inclusive of all types of people” and it “wo n’t tolerate any kind of racial animus” — and it also “wo n’t tolerate fictional racial animus”.
The school needs to do more, according to others, both those who were friendly to the racism claims and those who were more skeptical.
MORE: A dark scholar in Illinois is facing racism-related charges.
The college president has referenced the” complexities” of the case and referred to it as “nuanced”. President Bob Iuliano even mentioned” consent” during a Sept. university congress meeting.
” No matter the marriage, and no matter the determination, there is no area on this college for words or actions that degrade, damage, or marginalize based on one’s personality and history”, he said.
He furthermore reportedly told the university congress that” this is also one of the more complicated and complex cases I’ve seen in my day in higher training” and that he was just saying that.
He said more, as reported by the scholar news:
We’ve also been trying to be clear that I know people want us to talk about the details, but there is federal legislation that precludes us from doing so, and that’s unpleasant to us, it’s frustrating to pupils, it’s frustrating to the area.
But what I would say is, if you have a moment to just look at what has been talked about in the various settings in which it’s been talked about, you will begin to see some of the complexities that I’ve talked about, raising really important questions about consent, identity, accountability, race based trauma. How the college has attempted to respond to this is largely influenced by all of these complexities.
Francis, the legal scholar, ended The Fix interview by calling the situation a “bizarre story” and said it seemed like a “party trick gone wrong”.
The professor at Widener University referred to Jussie Smollett in a quote from the actor in Chicago who filed a false police report claiming racism. ” It seems eerily similar to that situation”.
MORE: There were 19 campus hate crime hoaxes in 2023
IMAGE: ABC 27/YouTube
Follow The College Fix on Twitter and Like us on Facebook.
